How to Spot Authentic Pre-Columbian Artifacts: Methods, Tricks, and Tests

Pre-Columbian artifacts created by ancient civilizations across the Americas are highly valued for their cultural and historical significance. However, the market is saturated with forgeries, replicas, and tourist souvenirs. While some advanced authentication methods should be left to seasoned professionals, several practical tests and tricks can be performed at home to assess an artifact’s authenticity. This guide will walk you through those methods and help you spot potential fakes and reproductions.

Note: This guide highlights only a selection of methods to help you spot fakes, as some advanced techniques are intentionally omitted to avoid providing information that might inadvertently help forgers improve their reproductions.

1. Research the Context and Provenance

Begin by researching the history of the artifact. Authentic pre-Columbian pieces typically have a detailed provenance, which traces the artifact’s ownership and discovery. Please verify that the piece aligns with the cultural and historical characteristics of its supposed origin, whether it be Mayan, Inca, Aztec, or another civilization.

If the provenance is incomplete or questionable, approach the purchase cautiously.

2. Examine the Materials

Pre-Columbian artifacts were crafted using natural materials like clay, stone, jade, and obsidian. Each civilization utilized these materials in specific ways, leaving behind telltale signs.

How to Test:

• Pottery: Authentic pre-Columbian pottery is handmade and typically shows irregularities. Ancient clays tend to have bits of stone and other debris and a muted, dull color, while modern clay is refined and often bright orange or white. If the vessel is painted, scratch the surface of a hidden area to expose the underlying substrate for evaluation. To further test its authenticity, tap the pottery lightly. Newer pottery produces a higher-pitched sound due to the higher temperatures used in modern firing techniques. In contrast, ancient pottery, fired at lower temperatures over a slower process, will have a duller, lower tone.
• Stone Artifacts: Real stone artifacts show signs of use, exposure, and weathering, such as surface erosion and mineral deposits. A fake will often appear too smooth and pristine and have sharp edges.

Red Flag: Be wary of overly perfect or exaggerated pieces. Authentic artifacts bear the marks of handcrafting, such as hand-tooled marks and irregularities.

3. Perform the Wet Test on Pottery

Another simple test for pottery involves water absorption. Ancient pottery tends to absorb water quickly, as the clay has degraded over time, and its pores are more open than modern pieces.

How to Test:

• Apply a small amount of water to the surface of the pottery. Observe how fast it is absorbed.
• If the piece is genuine and ancient, the water will be absorbed rapidly. As it penetrates the porous clay, it may release ancient trapped gases, emitting a distinct, pungent, earthy smell.
• If the vessel is painted, use a wet cotton swab to see if it is easily removed. Ancient pigments tend to be harder to remove.

Red Flag: A piece that does not absorb water quickly or lacks the dirty, musty odor may be a modern reproduction.

4. Check for Patina and Wear

Patina forms naturally on objects over time due to exposure to elements. Authentic pre-Columbian artifacts will have a patina consistent with centuries of aging. This can include color variations, surface deposits, and micro-scratches.

How to Test:

• Visual Inspection: Use a magnifying glass to inspect the surface. Look for color changes, wear, or deposits that form naturally over time. Additionally, inspect the surface for Manganese dendrites, which are branch-like mineral deposits that form over centuries on ancient surfaces, particularly stone artifacts. These natural mineral patterns can be a good indicator of authenticity.
• Touch Test: Feel the surface for uneven textures, which indicate long-term handling. Fake artifacts often feel overly smooth or artificially aged.

Red Flag: Uniform patinas or wear patterns across hard-to-reach areas of the artifact suggest a fake. Authentic pieces will show uneven wear from natural use, and the presence of manganese dendrites adds further credibility to the artifact’s age.

5. Examine the Craftsmanship

Pre-Columbian civilizations used rudimentary tools, so authentic artifacts are rarely perfect. Modern reproductions, made with advanced tools, often lack the subtle imperfections of handcrafting.

How to Test:

• Look for Tool Marks: You should see uneven marks from hand tools under magnification. Machine-made reproductions will have uniform markings or appear too smooth.
• Symmetry: Genuine ancient pieces are rarely perfectly symmetrical, as they were crafted by hand.

Red Flag: Perfect edges, polished surfaces, or overly symmetrical designs could indicate a forgery.

6. Look for Modern Restorations

While some authentic artifacts may have undergone restoration, modern repairs using substances like synthetic glues or fillers are red flags. Modern restorations can sometimes be used to pass off fakes as genuine.

How to Test:

• UV Light: Shine a UV light on the artifact. Many modern glues and paints will fluoresce, revealing areas where restoration or modern touch-ups have occurred.
• Visible Repairs: Look for signs of reattachment or filled-in gaps that seem out of place for a piece of the artifact’s supposed age.

Red Flag: If parts of the artifact glow under UV light or appear artificially repaired, the piece may be inauthentic or heavily restored.

7. Identify Folk Art and Tourist Souvenirs

Tourist souvenirs and folk art pieces often mimic pre-Columbian styles but lack the craftsmanship and materials of genuine artifacts. These reproductions are typically mass-produced and made from cheaper materials.

How to Test:

• Repetitive Designs: Look for mass-produced forms or repetitive patterns. Authentic pre-Columbian artifacts are unique, and each piece shows slight variations.
• Material Quality: Tourist souvenirs are often made from low-quality clay, resin, or other cheap materials, in contrast to the natural stone, clay, and minerals used in ancient times.

Red Flag: If the piece appears overly new or polished or looks like something commonly seen in souvenir shops, it’s likely a modern reproduction.

Conclusion

While there are advanced methods for authenticating pre-Columbian artifacts, many of which should be left to experts, the tests and tricks outlined here can help you assess pieces at home. You can avoid purchasing a fake or modern reproduction by paying attention to the materials, craftsmanship, and signs of age and performing simple tests like tapping pottery or the wet test. Additionally, looking for manganese dendrites on stone surfaces can provide further evidence of authenticity. When in doubt, seek professional authentication, especially for high-value artifacts.

Why a Certificate of Authenticity is Essential When Purchasing Artifacts

Research Academic Papers and News Articles